Method
How we rate knife sets
Every set gets one score out of 10, built from five parts. This page explains exactly how, and where the limits of our scores are.
- 25%
Steel
The grade of steel and how hard it is. Harder steel holds an edge longer.
- 25%
Build
Forged or stamped, full tang or not, and how the handle is fixed.
- 20%
Included
Whether the set has the knives you need, without filler.
- 20%
Value
The price against the specification, not the list price.
- 10%
Guarantee
Length of guarantee and how easy the set is to care for.
What our scores are based on
We have used every knife set we rate, and each one carries a Tested by uslabel. The score itself is worked out from each set's published specification: the steel grade, the hardness, how the knives are made, what comes in the box, the guarantee and the price, as stated by the maker and the retailer. We compare those facts across every set using the same rules.
We want to be straightforward about the limits. We do not run laboratory edge-retention tests, and a score on this site is not a laboratory measurement. Where a fact is not published, we say so in the review and score that part cautiously rather than guess.
Tested by us and research picks
Every product on this site carries one of two labels, so you can see how we know about it.
- Tested by us: we have used the product ourselves. Every knife set in our ranking has this label, and so do the single knives, whetstones and sharpeners currently named in our guides.
- Research pick:we chose the product from the retailer's published specification and have not used it yet. A newly added product carries this label until we have tested it.
The five criteria
| Criterion | Weight | What we look at |
|---|---|---|
| Steel | 25% | Named steel grade, hardness (HRC) and edge angle. Named grades score higher than an unspecified "stainless steel". |
| Build | 25% | Forged or stamped, full or partial tang, bolster, and how the handle is made and attached. |
| What is included | 20% | Whether the set covers chef's, bread, utility and paring knives without filler, plus storage and any honing steel or sharpener. |
| Value | 20% | The price we found against the specification. A cheap set with poor steel does not score well, and neither does a fine set at an inflated price. |
| Guarantee and care | 10% | Length and conditions of the guarantee, and how demanding the knives are to look after. |
Prices
Prices on this site are checked by hand, not fed live from retailers. The date of the last check is shown next to our lists (currently 13 November 2026). Sale prices in particular change often, so always confirm the price on the retailer's site before you buy. A "was" price is the standard or regular price the retailer itself displayed on the day we checked.
Independence
We earn a commission from some retailers when you buy through our links. Retailers cannot pay for a place in our ranking or for a better score, and commission rates play no part in the scoring. Our affiliate disclosure explains this in full.
Corrections
Makers change specifications and we can make mistakes. If you spot something wrong, email hello@knifeverdict.co.uk and we will check and correct it.
